Getting you a comprehensive review of the product
Reading every ingredient in the formula…
Reading every ingredient in the formula…
Join The Clean Sheet™ community
Science-backed beauty tips, ingredient alerts, and early access. Straight to your WhatsApp.
Join for free →
This Mamaearth lip balm offers a good, naturally-derived formula for daily lip care, but its ambitious claims for long-duration moisturization and UV protection are not fully substantiated by visible evidence.
₹225 • Analysed 23 July 2026
This Mamaearth lip balm is positioned as a natural, tinted, and moisturizing option for the Indian market, with a competitive price point around Rs.299 for 2g. Its claims of '100% Natural' and 'India's 1st Made Safe Certified' resonate with the growing demand for clean beauty in India, though the '100% Natural' and '1st' claims could face ASCI scrutiny for lack of specific substantiation. The formula, rich in oils and butters, is well-suited for providing hydration in India's varied climate, but the 'protects from UV damage' claim without an SPF rating is a significant gap for a country with high UV exposure.
Independent and free. The Clean Sheet takes no money from brands to review, rank, or approve a product. This is a web evidence review, not a Clean Sheet certification. We checked the ingredient list, publicly available test reports, marketing claims, and formula logic using only public information available at the time of review.
The INCI lists several naturally derived ingredients and waxes. However, '100% Natural' is an absolute claim that is difficult to verify without a clear industry standard definition and full disclosure of derivation methods for all ingredients. The presence of 'Berry Flavor' also needs clarification on its natural origin.
The product is visibly tinted and user reviews confirm a subtle rose tint. The INCI lists 'Rose Essential Oil' which could contribute to the tint or scent.
The INCI lists 'Castor Oil' (likely Ricinus Communis Seed Oil) and 'Rose Essential Oil'. Their presence supports the claim.
This is a quantified, time-bound claim. No finished-product clinical study or instrumental test data (sample size, methodology, results) is publicly visible to substantiate the 12-hour duration.
Ingredients like Shea Butter, Castor Oil, and Coconut Oil are known emollients and occlusives that can help soothe and protect dry, chapped lips. However, 'heals' is a strong performance claim, and no finished-product evidence is publicly visible to demonstrate this specific healing action.
The brand consistently claims 'India's 1st Made Safe Certified lip balm'. Made Safe is a third-party certification for products free from known toxins. This provides external validation for the safety claims.
Supported by the 'Made Safe Certified' claim, which implies screening for known toxins.
The retrieved INCI list does not contain ingredients typically identified as Silicones (e.g., Dimethicone), Parabens (e.g., Methylparaben), Mineral Oil (Paraffinum Liquidum), or synthetic Dyes. The INCI does not list common synthetic preservatives like Phenoxyethanol, relying on natural alternatives or the anhydrous nature of the balm.
What we could confirm from public sources and the verified ingredient list.
Ingredient Safety & Toxicity
Full ingredient list retrieved and verified against the label.
Brand describes ingredient origin in its claims.
Screened against the ingredient database (6 of 18 ingredients matched); no cosmetics-prohibited ingredient found.
No ingredient with a recognised endocrine-activity concern found in the database.
No IARC-classified or formaldehyde-releasing ingredient found in the database screen.
Irritation & Allergen Risk
No EU-declarable or database-flagged allergen found in the list.
No high-sensitisation preservative (MI/MCI/formaldehyde-releaser) from our screen was found.
Ingredient Transparency
The full INCI list is publicly available, not just hero ingredients.
Ingredients are listed in the descending order required by India Cosmetics Rules 2020.
Standards & Compliance
Usage warnings and directions are clear on the label.
Screened against a curated reference set that we are continuing to verify and expand, so “clear” means no flag from that set, not a guarantee. Not a substitute for a full toxicological or clinical assessment.
| Ingredient |
|---|
Castor Oil |
Organic Coconut Oil |
Dicaprylyl Carbonate |
Shea Butter |
Carnauba Wax |
Candelilla Wax |
Cetearyl Olivate |
Sorbitan Olivate |
Honey |
Berry Flavor |
Rose Essential Oil |
Oleic Acid |
Linoleic Acid |
Linolenic Acid |
Vitamin E |
Hydroxytyrosol |
Maslinic Acid |
Oleanolic Acid |
INCI order as declared on packaging. Position reflects approximate concentration (high to low).
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
Flags are based on publicly available INCI only. Not a substitute for full regulatory compliance review.
“100% Natural Lip Balm”
Absolute claims like '100% Natural' can be misleading if not all components are derived directly from nature or if processing involves synthetic steps, per ASCI guidelines on truthful advertising.
“12-hour moisturization”
Quantified claims like '12-hour moisturization' require robust, verifiable scientific evidence, typically a clinical study, to comply with ASCI guidelines. Without such evidence, the claim is unsubstantiated.
“Protects them from UV damage”
Claiming 'protects from UV damage' without an SPF rating and supporting test data can be misleading, as consumers may assume adequate sun protection. ASCI requires substantiation for such functional claims.
“India's 1st Made Safe Certified lip balm”
The 'India's 1st' claim requires verifiable comparative data and methodology to be compliant with ASCI guidelines. Without this, it is an unsubstantiated superiority claim.
The INCI lists several naturally derived ingredients and waxes. However, '100% Natural' is an absolute claim that is difficult to verify without a clear industry standard definition and full disclosure of derivation methods for all ingredients. The presence of 'Berry Flavor' also needs clarification on its natural origin.
Mentioned only
The product is visibly tinted and user reviews confirm a subtle rose tint. The INCI lists 'Rose Essential Oil' which could contribute to the tint or scent.
Evidence visible
The INCI lists 'Castor Oil' (likely Ricinus Communis Seed Oil) and 'Rose Essential Oil'. Their presence supports the claim.
Mentioned only
This is a quantified, time-bound claim. No finished-product clinical study or instrumental test data (sample size, methodology, results) is publicly visible to substantiate the 12-hour duration.
Missing
Ingredients like Shea Butter, Castor Oil, and Coconut Oil are known emollients and occlusives that can help soothe and protect dry, chapped lips. However, 'heals' is a strong performance claim, and no finished-product evidence is publicly visible to demonstrate this specific healing action.
Mentioned only
The brand consistently claims 'India's 1st Made Safe Certified lip balm'. Made Safe is a third-party certification for products free from known toxins. This provides external validation for the safety claims.
Evidence visible
Supported by the 'Made Safe Certified' claim, which implies screening for known toxins.
Evidence visible
The retrieved INCI list does not contain ingredients typically identified as Silicones (e.g., Dimethicone), Parabens (e.g., Methylparaben), Mineral Oil (Paraffinum Liquidum), or synthetic Dyes. The INCI does not list common synthetic preservatives like Phenoxyethanol, relying on natural alternatives or the anhydrous nature of the balm.
Evidence visible
Ingredients like Castor Oil, Shea Butter, Coconut Oil, and various waxes provide occlusive and emollient properties that can offer lasting moisture. However, 'long-lasting' is subjective and lacks specific finished-product evidence.
Mentioned only
Emollient ingredients like Shea Butter, Castor Oil, and Coconut Oil are known to soften skin. This claim is consistent with the ingredient profile.
Mentioned only
Public evidence the brand could provide to close verification gaps
This review evaluates brand claims against visible evidence and formula logic. It does not replace a full ingredient safety analysis or a clinical product test. Results vary by individual, and the consumer should always read the full ingredient list and follow usage guidance.
Are you the brand? If you have published test data or want to request a re-review, write to us at hello@thecleansheet.in.
No ingredient with a recognised endocrine-activity concern found in the database.
No IARC-classified or formaldehyde-releasing ingredient found in the database screen.
Irritation & Allergen Risk
No EU-declarable or database-flagged allergen found in the list.
No high-sensitisation preservative (MI/MCI/formaldehyde-releaser) from our screen was found.
Ingredient Transparency
The full INCI list is publicly available, not just hero ingredients.
Ingredients are listed in the descending order required by India Cosmetics Rules 2020.
Standards & Compliance
Usage warnings and directions are clear on the label.
Screened against a curated reference set that we are continuing to verify and expand, so “clear” means no flag from that set, not a guarantee. Not a substitute for a full toxicological or clinical assessment.
This is a quantified, time-bound claim. No finished-product clinical study or instrumental test data (sample size, methodology, results) is publicly visible to substantiate the 12-hour duration.
Ingredients like Shea Butter, Castor Oil, and Coconut Oil are known emollients and occlusives that can help soothe and protect dry, chapped lips. However, 'heals' is a strong performance claim, and no finished-product evidence is publicly visible to demonstrate this specific healing action.
The brand consistently claims 'India's 1st Made Safe Certified lip balm'. Made Safe is a third-party certification for products free from known toxins. This provides external validation for the safety claims.
Supported by the 'Made Safe Certified' claim, which implies screening for known toxins.
The retrieved INCI list does not contain ingredients typically identified as Silicones (e.g., Dimethicone), Parabens (e.g., Methylparaben), Mineral Oil (Paraffinum Liquidum), or synthetic Dyes. The INCI does not list common synthetic preservatives like Phenoxyethanol, relying on natural alternatives or the anhydrous nature of the balm.
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
No prohibited or restricted ingredients identified
Flags are based on publicly available INCI only. Not a substitute for full regulatory compliance review.
The INCI lists several naturally derived ingredients and waxes. However, '100% Natural' is an absolute claim that is difficult to verify without a clear industry standard definition and full disclosure of derivation methods for all ingredients. The presence of 'Berry Flavor' also needs clarification on its natural origin.
Mentioned only
The product is visibly tinted and user reviews confirm a subtle rose tint. The INCI lists 'Rose Essential Oil' which could contribute to the tint or scent.
Evidence visible
The INCI lists 'Castor Oil' (likely Ricinus Communis Seed Oil) and 'Rose Essential Oil'. Their presence supports the claim.
Mentioned only
This is a quantified, time-bound claim. No finished-product clinical study or instrumental test data (sample size, methodology, results) is publicly visible to substantiate the 12-hour duration.
Missing
Ingredients like Shea Butter, Castor Oil, and Coconut Oil are known emollients and occlusives that can help soothe and protect dry, chapped lips. However, 'heals' is a strong performance claim, and no finished-product evidence is publicly visible to demonstrate this specific healing action.
Mentioned only
The brand consistently claims 'India's 1st Made Safe Certified lip balm'. Made Safe is a third-party certification for products free from known toxins. This provides external validation for the safety claims.
Evidence visible
Supported by the 'Made Safe Certified' claim, which implies screening for known toxins.
Evidence visible
The retrieved INCI list does not contain ingredients typically identified as Silicones (e.g., Dimethicone), Parabens (e.g., Methylparaben), Mineral Oil (Paraffinum Liquidum), or synthetic Dyes. The INCI does not list common synthetic preservatives like Phenoxyethanol, relying on natural alternatives or the anhydrous nature of the balm.
Evidence visible
Ingredients like Castor Oil, Shea Butter, Coconut Oil, and various waxes provide occlusive and emollient properties that can offer lasting moisture. However, 'long-lasting' is subjective and lacks specific finished-product evidence.
Mentioned only
Emollient ingredients like Shea Butter, Castor Oil, and Coconut Oil are known to soften skin. This claim is consistent with the ingredient profile.
Mentioned only
“100% Natural Lip Balm”
Absolute claims like '100% Natural' can be misleading if not all components are derived directly from nature or if processing involves synthetic steps, per ASCI guidelines on truthful advertising.
“12-hour moisturization”
Quantified claims like '12-hour moisturization' require robust, verifiable scientific evidence, typically a clinical study, to comply with ASCI guidelines. Without such evidence, the claim is unsubstantiated.
“Protects them from UV damage”
Claiming 'protects from UV damage' without an SPF rating and supporting test data can be misleading, as consumers may assume adequate sun protection. ASCI requires substantiation for such functional claims.
“India's 1st Made Safe Certified lip balm”
The 'India's 1st' claim requires verifiable comparative data and methodology to be compliant with ASCI guidelines. Without this, it is an unsubstantiated superiority claim.
Public evidence the brand could provide to close verification gaps
