The Clean Sheet
63
Dot & Keysunscreen

Watermelon Cooling Sunscreen SPF 50 PA+++

Fair

Watermelon Cooling Sunscreen SPF 50 PA+++

Sun protection

INCI VerifiedSPF 50 PA+++Oily / Combination SkinBenzophenone-3 (Oxybenzone) - Endocrine Disruptor RiskSynthetic Fragrance (Leave-On)Not Recommended for Sensitive SkinNot Reef-SafeOctinoxate Present
7
Safe
0
Note
3
Caution
₹399-₹695Analysed 20 May 2026
Watermelon Cooling Sunscreen SPF 50 PA+++
Key Actives
Benzophenone-3 (Oxybenzone)
UVA/UVB filter, high INCI position suggests >5%; in-vitro endocrine disruption evidence, FDA additional safety data requested, banned for reef protection in Hawaii
Ethylhexyl Methoxycinnamate
UVB filter (Octinoxate), widely used; under active EU and FDA endocrine disruption review, known reef pollutant
Watermelon (Citrullus Lanatus) Extract
Antioxidant, soothing, marketed hero ingredient
Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice
Soothing, humectant
Expert Summary

The brand's most popular sunscreen, but carries the most significant safety concern in the range: Benzophenone-3 (Oxybenzone) appears at a high INCI position, estimated >5% based on order relative to other actives. Benzophenone-3 has evidence for endocrine disruption in in-vitro studies, is banned for reef protection in Hawaii, and is restricted in some EU cosmetic applications. The product also contains Parfum (fragrance), compounding irritation potential. UV protection is adequate (SPF 50/PA+++) but the filter choice is a meaningful formulation concern relative to newer alternatives.

Score Breakdown
63/100 points
Safety & ToxicityFair

Benzophenone-3 (Oxybenzone) appears at a high position in the INCI list, indicating a significant concentration — estimated above 5% based on its placement relative to other actives. ECHA formally classified Oxybenzone as a Category 1 Endocrine Disruptor in 2025. The FDA has requested additional safety data, and it is banned in marine-protected areas in Hawaii and Palau due to coral reef toxicity. The EU is currently reassessing permitted concentrations. Daily face application represents meaningful chronic exposure given the liberal quantities required for effective sun protection. Ethylhexyl Methoxycinnamate (Octinoxate) is also present; it is separately under active EU and FDA review for potential endocrine disruption and is a recognised reef pollutant. Parfum (synthetic fragrance) is listed as a single ingredient without any disclosure of its constituent allergens. Fragrance is the leading class of contact allergen in skincare, and applying an undisclosed fragrance mixture liberally over the face daily carries meaningful sensitisation risk.

Formulation Quality & EfficacyStrong

SPF 50 PA+++ provides solid sun protection, and Watermelon extract alongside Aloe Vera contribute soothing and hydration. The UV protection function is real. The notable formulation gap is the choice of Benzophenone-3 as a key UV filter — the brand's own Vitamin C + E Sunscreen (which scores higher) uses a modern, photostable filter system (Tinosorb S, Uvinul A Plus, Ethylhexyl Triazone) without these safety concerns, which makes the filter choice here a meaningful step back.

Ingredient Disclosure & TransparencyStrong

SPF 50 PA+++ is claimed but the brand does not publish a test report on the product page. Without a published SPF test, consumers cannot independently verify the stated protection level. The full INCI is published and all UV filters are identifiable. Parfum is listed but without any constituent allergen breakdown. Notably, the brand's product descriptions do not acknowledge the safety concerns associated with Benzophenone-3, so consumers browsing the product page receive no context to make an informed comparison.

Ethics & SustainabilityConcern

Benzophenone-3 is banned in several marine-protected areas due to documented coral reef toxicity. Ethylhexyl Methoxycinnamate also carries reef toxicity risk. Both UV filters are recognised aquatic pollutants that enter waterways through rinsing and ocean swimming. Synthetic fragrance with undisclosed composition is also present. Packaging is plastic.

🇮🇳
India Skin Context

For Indian consumers: Benzophenone-3 is particularly concerning given India's high UV intensity requiring liberal, frequent application, increasing systemic absorption potential. The brand's Vitamin C + E Sunscreen (score: 81) uses modern UV filters without these concerns and is the recommended Dot & Key SPF option.

Full Ingredient List
Safe Note Caution
IngredientNoteStatus
Aqua (Water)
Solvent baseSafe
Benzophenone-3
UV filter (Oxybenzone), high INCI position suggests significant concentration. Evidence for endocrine disruption in in-vitro studies. FDA has requested further safety data. Banned for reef protection in Hawaii.Caution
Ethylhexyl Methoxycinnamate
UVB filter (Octinoxate), effective, widely used; under active EU and FDA endocrine disruption review, known reef pollutant.Caution
Citrullus Lanatus (Watermelon) Fruit Extract
Antioxidant, skin-soothing, low functional concentration likelySafe
Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice
Soothing, hydratingSafe
Glycerin
Humectant, safe, widely studiedSafe
Butylene Glycol
Humectant and solventSafe
Parfum
Fragrance, irritation risk; particularly concerning in a product applied liberally to face. Top class of contact allergen; constituent allergens not disclosed.Caution
Phenoxyethanol
Preservative at typical cosmetic concentrationSafe
Ethylhexylglycerin
Co-preservative, skin conditioningSafe

Ingredients listed in INCI order as declared on product packaging. Position reflects approximate concentration (high → low).

About this scorecard

Clean Sheet Scores are generated by analysing every ingredient against India, EU, US & Korean safety regulations. No brand sponsorship. No affiliate relationships. Independent science-backed analysis only.

The Clean Sheet does not use fear-based ingredient labels. We assess products through a structured evidence hierarchy:

  • What global regulations say
  • What toxicology says
  • What the formula concentration shows
  • What the product format changes
  • What the intended user needs
  • What testing evidence proves
  • What the brand is claiming
Analyse another product
WhatsApp Community

Join The Clean Sheet™ community

Science-backed beauty tips, ingredient alerts, and early access. Straight to your WhatsApp.

Join for free →