The Clean Sheet
46
Pilgrimleave on

Red Vine + Retinol Night Gel Creme

Concern

Red Vine + Retinol Night Gel Creme

Anti-ageing, fine lines, overnight renewal

Paraben-FreeCruelty-Free (PETA)Parfum in Leave-On Retinol ProductDual Azo Dyes (No Functional Benefit)Retinol % UndisclosedAvoid During PregnancyNot Recommended for Sensitive Skin
12
Safe
2
Note
3
Caution
Rs. 599 - Rs. 999Analysed 20 May 2026
Red Vine + Retinol Night Gel Creme
Key Actives
Retinol
Vitamin A alcohol, stimulates collagen synthesis, accelerates cell turnover, reduces fine lines and wrinkles; concentration undisclosed
Vitis Vinifera (Grape) Seed Extract
Proanthocyanidin antioxidant, free radical quenching, collagen-protective
Resveratrol
Polyphenol antioxidant from grape, SIRT1 pathway signalling
Expert Summary

A retinol-positioning night cream combining Vitis Vinifera extracts with Retinol as the active retinoid. Significant concerns: Parfum (synthetic fragrance compound mixture) is present in a leave-on retinol product - retinol already increases skin sensitivity and inflammation risk, and fragrance allergens compound that over 8+ hours of overnight contact. Additionally, two azo dyes (CI 16035 and CI 45380) are present as cosmetic colourants with no functional benefit, adding unnecessary allergen load to a leave-on night treatment. Retinol concentration is undisclosed. The combination of Parfum, dual azo dyes, and undisclosed-concentration retinol in an overnight leave-on format represents a significant formulation concern.

Score Breakdown
49/100 points
Safety & ToxicityFair

Parfum (synthetic fragrance blend) is present in a leave-on retinol product that sits on skin for 8 or more hours overnight. Retinol increases skin permeability, which means fragrance allergens penetrate more deeply and remain in contact with skin longer than in a rinse-off or fragrance-free product. Parfum is a single entry that can contain hundreds of individual compounds; EU Regulation 1223/2009 Annex III requires that individual fragrance allergens present above 0.001% in leave-on products be named separately. Listing only 'Parfum' does not meet that disclosure standard. CI 16035 (Allura Red azo dye) and CI 45380 (a fluorescein derivative dye) are both contact allergens with no therapeutic function in a retinol night treatment. The retinol concentration is not disclosed; below about 0.025%, retinol is generally considered sub-functional, which would make the retinoid claim difficult to substantiate. Dimethicone and Cetearyl Alcohol are well-tolerated emollients with no safety concerns.

Formulation Quality & EfficacyFair

Retinol is the most robustly evidenced retinoid for stimulating collagen, reducing fine lines, and accelerating cell turnover. The gel-creme base with Cetearyl Alcohol, Cetearyl Glucoside, and Dimethicone provides suitable emollient and occlusive support for overnight use. The undisclosed retinol concentration is a significant gap: without knowing the dose, there is no way to assess whether the retinoid is present at a level that can deliver the anti-ageing results the product claims. Parfum introduces an inflammatory risk that compounds over the full overnight contact period, working against the skin renewal retinol is intended to support. The two azo dyes add no formulation benefit.

Ingredient Disclosure & TransparencyConcern

The full INCI list is published on the product page. Retinol concentration is not disclosed - this is the most important number in this product, and without it consumers cannot judge whether the retinoid is present at a dose that does anything meaningful. Parfum is listed as a single entry without a breakdown of individual allergen components, which does not meet the EU Regulation 1223/2009 Annex III requirement for named allergen disclosure in leave-on products. The two azo dyes are present with no explanation of their role in product marketing. The product does not carry a pregnancy warning, despite containing a retinoid ingredient - retinoids are universally contraindicated during pregnancy. No clinical study data has been published for this formula.

Ethics & SustainabilityFair

Pilgrim is PETA-certified cruelty-free. The brand does not sell into markets that require mandatory animal testing. Parfum and two synthetic azo dyes all appear on the COSMOS prohibited ingredients list, meaning this product would not qualify for any natural cosmetics certification. Dimethicone (silicone) is similarly COSMOS-prohibited. The formula has not been verified as vegan due to ingredient complexity.

🇮🇳
India Skin Context

Retinol is the gold standard topical for anti-ageing across all skin tones and is particularly valuable for Fitzpatrick III-V tones in India where photodamage, melasma, and PIH co-exist. However, retinol already increases skin sensitivity - adding synthetic fragrance and two cosmetic dyes to a night treatment that remains on skin for 8+ hours creates a cumulative sensitisation environment that works against the product's own goals. Indian consumers seeking a reliable retinol night product should look for fragrance-free, dye-free formulas with disclosed retinol concentrations. Not recommended during pregnancy or breastfeeding. Avoid if you have sensitive, eczema-prone, or rosacea-affected skin.

Full Ingredient List
Safe Note Caution
IngredientNoteStatus
Aqua
Solvent baseSafe
Glycerin
HumectantSafe
Propanediol
Plant-derived humectant and solventSafe
Vitis Vinifera (Grape) Seed Extract
Proanthocyanidin antioxidantSafe
Retinol
Vitamin A alcohol, effective retinoid; concentration undisclosed by brand - sub-0.025% concentration would be sub-functionalNote
Resveratrol
Polyphenol from grape skin, antioxidantSafe
Niacinamide
Vitamin B3, barrier support and anti-inflammatory; helps offset retinol-induced sensitivitySafe
Sodium Hyaluronate
HA salt for overnight hydrationSafe
Butylene Glycol
Humectant and solvent, low concernSafe
Cetearyl Alcohol
Fatty alcohol emollient, emulsifier component; appropriate for night cream vehicleSafe
Cetearyl Glucoside
Sugar-derived emulsifier, well-toleratedSafe
Dimethicone
Silicone occlusive, supports overnight moisture retention; COSMOS-prohibited but not a safety concernSafe
Parfum
Synthetic fragrance mixture in a leave-on retinol night product; retinol increases skin permeability, amplifying allergen exposure over 8+ hour contact; EU Annex III individual allergen disclosure requirement not met by a single 'Parfum' entryCaution
CI 16035
Allura Red AC azo dye, no functional benefit in a leave-on product, contact allergen in sensitised individualsCaution
CI 45380
Fluorescein derivative dye, no functional benefit in leave-on, additional allergen load compounding retinol sensitisation riskCaution
Phenoxyethanol
Preservative within EU/India 1% limitNote
Ethylhexylglycerin
Preservative booster, very low concernSafe

Ingredients listed in INCI order as declared on product packaging. Position reflects approximate concentration (high → low).

About this scorecard

Clean Sheet Scores are generated by analysing every ingredient against India, EU, US & Korean safety regulations. No brand sponsorship. No affiliate relationships. Independent science-backed analysis only.

The Clean Sheet does not use fear-based ingredient labels. We assess products through a structured evidence hierarchy:

  • What global regulations say
  • What toxicology says
  • What the formula concentration shows
  • What the product format changes
  • What the intended user needs
  • What testing evidence proves
  • What the brand is claiming
Analyse another product
WhatsApp Community

Join The Clean Sheet™ community

Science-backed beauty tips, ingredient alerts, and early access. Straight to your WhatsApp.

Join for free →